Delicious and Easy Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding Recipe

Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding

In New York City’s heart, Magnolia Bakery is well known for its delicious desserts. Also known as a haven for dessert enthusiasts, their Banana Pudding is the favorite of people of all ages. A classic American dessert that has won the hearts of people across the country with its rich, creamy texture, flavor, and taste.

While we would all enjoy a trip to Magnolia Bakery, why not bring the taste and magic of the pudding into your kitchen? This blog will explore the step-by-step process of creating, presenting, and serving this delicious dessert.

Join us as we explore the secrets behind this tasty masterpiece and savor the bliss of one of America’s favorite desserts in the comfort of your home.

But, before heading ahead, let us first dive into the rich past of the special Magnolia Bakery.

The Legacy of Magnolia Bakery

The Legacy of Magnolia Bakery

Magnolia Bakery, founded in 1996, has a prominent name in the books of American dessert history. The bakery has become an iconic part of America, celebrating its rich heritage and delicious creations.

The bakery started in New York City’s West Village, where the founders, Allysa Torey and Jennifer Appel, created an inviting space that brought back the charm of old-fashioned bakeries. The bakery became famous as a small shop due to its dedicated quality and the founders’ passion.

The main focus of the founders was to create timeless classics and their commitment to using the best ingredients available. From cupcakes to pies and other treats, the bakery won the hearts of tourists and locals. One reason that put the bakery in the scene is their special Banana Pudding, a savory dessert that took the dessert world by storm.

As word spread, visitors from around the globe flocked around the bakery to taste the creamy layers of this pudding, ripe bananas, and the crispy Nilla wafer cookie used in this dessert.

The Star: Banana Pudding – Requirements

This deliciously prominent dessert has managed to charm the hearts of dessert enthusiasts across the globe, making it one of the most deserving must-try desserts for bakers across the globe. The charm of Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding lies in its simplicity. At first, it may look like a simple tub with layers of vanilla pudding, bananas, and Nila wafers.

Yet, this dessert exceeds expectations and converts these ingredients into a mix of flavors that dance on your tongue. The base layer is a creamy vanilla pudding with a velvety texture and a pliant balance of sweet and subtle taste of vanilla, adding richness to it.

The star of the dessert is the bananas, ripe but firm, where each slice adds natural sweetness to it. The mix of bananas with creamy pudding provides a harmony of flavors for you to enjoy. The surprise element of magnolia bakery banana pudding is the Nilla Wafers. They soak up the creamy essence and give a slight crunch, adding distinctiveness to the dessert experience.

1. Ingredients


Items Required


Heavy Cream

2 Cups

Sweetened Condensed Milk

1 Can (14 oz)

Instant Vanilla Pudding Mix

1 Pack (3.4 oz)

Ripe Bananas


Whole Milk

3 cups

Nilla wafers

1 Box (11 oz)

2. Tools Required

Tools Required

Mixing Bowls

Whisk/Electric Mixer

Trifle Dish

Cling Film



How to Make Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding

Once you have gathered the finest ingredients to replicate the dish, read on and learn how to make this delicious dessert in the comfort of your home. There are three significant steps to create your version of Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding: Preparing the pudding base, Layering the dessert, chilling, and enjoying.

1. Preparing the Pudding Base

Preparing the Pudding Base

Making the creamy vanilla pudding is the main focus of Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding. You can achieve the desired texture of the pudding with these simple steps that form the base of this delicious dessert. Mix 2 cups of heavy cream and 1 (14 oz) can of sweetened condensed milk in a large bowl, adding richness to the pudding. Add a pack of instant vanilla pudding mix to thicken the pudding and whisk vigorously.

Add 3 cups of whole milk and whisk again to reach the perfect consistency. The pudding will thicken as you whisk, creating a smooth and velvety texture. Making sure that there are no lumps in the pudding, you’re one step closer to making the ultimate Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding at home.

2. Layering the Pudding

Layering the Pudding

Layering the pudding is where the magic lies, as the delicate layers combine to offer you the perfect blend of flavors and textures. Take a trifle dish to display the dessert in all its glory. Begin the layering process by placing the Nilla wafers at the base. Add a layer of ripe sliced bananas on top of the wafers.

Once the bananas are in place to provide a natural sweetness to the pudding, generously spread a layer of vanilla pudding on top. Repeat the process till the ingredients are all used up. You can garnish the pudding with Nilla wafers to give that final crunch with each spoonful of pudding.

3. Chill and Serve

Chill and Serve

Once the Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding is carefully layered and you run out of ingredients, the final step would be to chill the dessert and enjoy it afterward. Cover the trifle dish with cling film to seal it firmly. Refrigerate the pudding for at least 4 hours or overnight for a supreme experience, allowing the flavors to merge and making the dessert tastier.

The pudding infuses with the Nilla wafers and bananas as time passes, enhancing the flavors. As you take the pudding out of the refrigerator and uncover it, you’ll be welcomed by the sweet aroma of vanilla and ripe bananas, heightening your excitement. Dive into the pudding spoon by spoon and savor this homemade Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding.

Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding – A Mixture of Flavors

Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding - A Mixture of Flavors

Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding is a mixture of flavors that stay on your taste buds. Each spoonful mixes vanilla pudding, freshly cut bananas, and Nilla wafers that enhance the experience. The indulgent flavors of the vanilla pudding provide balance to the other components.

The ripe and fresh bananas complement the pudding. The fresh slices give a natural sweetness to the dessert while adding texture to it. The soft and firm consistency creates a subtle contrast against the soft pudding.

The Nilla wafers absorb the pudding flavors, and the slightly soft yet crunchy bananas complement and complete the flavor palette—the buttery taste and smooth texture blend to give Magnolia Bakery banana pudding an unmatched taste. The carefully chosen items’ simplicity and detailing contribute to this marvel’s overall taste.

The Magnolia Bakery Difference – Home Made

The Magnolia Bakery Difference - Home Made

What sets the Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding apart from other desserts is the ‘Magnolia Bakery Difference,’ which goes beyond the texture, taste, consistency, and presentation right in your kitchen by using the finest and best possible ingredients while making the pudding and getting the highest level of freshness. Source the best quality vanilla, bananas, and Nilla wafers.

While making the pudding, opt for premium vanilla extracts to infuse it with a rich flavor, whisk the ingredients carefully, and take time to create a lump-free mixture. While layering, remember that presentation is the key.

Take your time evenly distributing the bananas, pudding, and wafers to create a visually appealing dish. The most crucial step is to let the dish chill and allow the flavors to meld together to provide you with the heavenly experience Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding is known for.

The ‘Magnolia Bakery Difference’ shines through every spoonful of your dessert, offering you satisfaction and flavor that dances on your tongue. Share it with your family and friends and witness their joy as they dig into the delicacy you created at home from scratch.

Variations and Customization for Banana Pudding

While this pudding is a culinary masterpiece, you can customize it in any way possible to enhance your dessert experience with multiple folds and take up your designing experience to a wholesome degree of value and intrigue

1. Addition of Fresh Strawberries

Addition of Fresh Strawberries

The tanginess of the strawberries complements the creamy texture and ripe bananas of the Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding and gives a burst of fruity goodness. This offers refreshing dimensions that make it a perfect choice for warm months.

2. Chocolate Pudding

Chocolate Pudding

You can choose this option if you prefer chocolate. This replaces the delectable vanilla pudding with a luscious chocolate pudding while keeping the other layers the same, taking the experience of their pudding to new heights. In addition to this, you can also alter the pudding to suit your taste. Adjusting the sweetness, extra bananas, peanut butter, or fruit toppings.

Calorie Count

The calorie count for Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding (small cup) typically adds around 330 calories. A delicacy that is rich in fat and carbs. It may have a low protein value, but the flavor makes up for it while enjoying it with friends and family.


Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding is more than just a dessert; it is a mix of flavors and textures that leaves a mark on your taste buds. The velvety pudding, paired with ripe and fresh bananas and Nilla wafers, creates a masterpiece that resonates with your taste buds and your soul.

Each spoonful takes you through a blend of items showcasing the bakery’s brilliance. Use the finest ingredients, pay attention to detail, and enjoy the dessert layer by layer. Savor the magic of Magnolia Bakery banana pudding right at your home.

We hope our blog helps you create your version of the Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding and provides insight into the bakery’s brilliance. If you haven’t yet experienced the bliss of this pudding, the time is now. Unleash your inner baker to create and indulge in this flavorful treat and enter culinary heaven.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why Do I Need to Cool the Pudding Down?

It is essential to chill the pudding for the settlement of ingredients. From 4 hours to overnight, it depends on how much you can control your urge to indulge in this delectable dessert. You won’t want your final product watery.

What is the Best Way to Mix the Pudding Mixture?

Mix and fold; that is the best way to mix anything. Use a spatula to fold the mixture or an electric mixer to mix the pudding mixture until the peaks stiffen evenly.

Jamie Oliver
Jamie Oliver

Jamie Oliver is a culinary maestro with over 25 years of experience who brings a wealth of knowledge to our culinary section. He graduated with honors in Culinary Arts and Food Service Management, which laid the groundwork for his illustrious career. He holds a Master’s in Gastronomy and has enriched our culinary content since 2017. His prior experience includes executive chef positions at high-end eateries and authoring several cookbooks. And his approach to cooking emphasizes sustainability and locally sourced ingredients. He is a great gardener as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *