Expert Recommendations: 11 Must-Try Tequilas for Margaritas

Top Best Tequilas for Margaritas: Expert Recommendations and Reviews

Imagine lounging by the pool, soaking up the sun, and craving a refreshing margarita.

But not just any margarita – one crafted with the perfect tequila to elevate your cocktail experience.

The secret to a truly unforgettable margarita is selecting the right tequila; we’ve got you covered.

Prepare to be amazed as we unveil 11 must-try tequilas that will take your margarita game to the next level.

From smooth blancos to rich reposados, these carefully chosen tequilas will tantalize your taste buds and leave you thirsting for more.

So, grab your shaker, salt the rim of your glass, and get ready to discover the ultimate tequilas for crafting margaritas that will impress even the most discerning palates.

Let’s dive in!

Brief History of the Margarita

The margarita, a cocktail beloved worldwide, has a rich history with roots in Mexican culture.

Believed to have originated in the 1930s or 1940s, its creation is attributed to various legends, including Tijuana bartenders and Acapulco socialites.

One popular story credits Carlos “Danny” Herrera with creating the drink for a customer allergic to all spirits except tequila.

Despite varying accounts, the margarita’s appeal has endured, making it a staple in cocktail culture.

Importance of Tequila in Making the Perfect Margarita

Importance of Tequila in Making the Perfect Margarita

Tequila is the cornerstone of a perfect margarita, directly influencing its flavor and quality.

Its unique characteristics, derived from the blue Weber agave plant, impart distinct flavors that set the foundation for the cocktail.

Choosing the right tequila is crucial; a high-quality tequila can elevate the drink, while a poor-quality one can ruin it.

Different types of tequila (blanco, reposado, añejo) offer varying flavor profiles, allowing for customization of the margarita experience.

11 Tequilas for Margaritas 

1. Tequila Ocho Plata

Tequila Ocho Plata

Tequila Ocho Plata is a vibrant, unaged tequila that captures the essence of its terroir.

It is known for its pure, unadulterated agave flavor, making it a top choice among tequila connoisseurs.

This tequila is perfect for crafting classic margaritas, allowing the agave’s natural flavors to shine through.

Tequila Ocho Plata features bright citrus notes, particularly lime and grapefruit, and fresh herbal undertones.

These flavors provide a refreshing and invigorating taste that complements the margarita’s other ingredients.

Tequila Ocho is renowned for its artisanal production process, which involves slow-cooking the agave in traditional brick ovens and extracting the agave juice using a tahona stone.

2. Casco Viejo Tequila Blanco

Casco Viejo Tequila Blanco

Casco Viejo Tequila Blanco is a budget-friendly option with exceptional quality and flavor.

It offers excellent value for those looking to make delicious margaritas without breaking the bank.

This tequila is great for making large batches of margaritas for parties or gatherings, such as pitcher margaritas. 

Casco Viejo Tequila Blanco boasts a rich, authentic agave flavor with hints of peppery spice and citrus notes.

The peppery notes add a pleasant kick to the margarita, while the citrus complements the lime juice.

This tequila works well in margaritas and other cocktails like the Paloma and can also be enjoyed neat.

3. Tequila Zarpado Blanco

Tequila Zarpado Blanco

Tequila Zarpado Blanco is an affordable and flavorful option that delivers a smooth and enjoyable tequila experience.

It balances quality and affordability, making it a great choice for casual margarita lovers.

This tequila is perfect for crafting everyday margaritas, whether you’re relaxing at home or entertaining friends.

Tequila Zarpado Blanco showcases a prominent peppery profile, followed by a rich agave core.

The peppery notes give the margarita a pleasant spiciness, while the agave provides a foundation of authentic flavor.

This tequila has received positive reviews from critics and consumers alike, praising its quality and value.

4. Milagro Reposado

Milagro Reposado

Milagro Reposado is a smooth and sophisticated tequila aged four to six months in American oak barrels.

This aging process imparts a depth of flavor and complexity that elevates the margarita experience.

Milagro Reposado is ideal for creating well-balanced margaritas with a touch of elegance.

During its time in oak barrels, Milagro Reposado develops enticing flavors of caramel, vanilla, and subtle spices like cinnamon and allspice.

These notes add a layer of richness to the margarita, complementing the citrus and agave flavors.

Milagro Tequila is crafted using 100% blue agave harvested from the Jalisco Highlands.

The agave is slow-roasted in traditional brick ovens, and the tequila undergoes a triple distillation process for exceptional smoothness.

5. La Gran Señora Reposado

La Gran Señora Reposado

La Gran Señora Reposado is an elegant and refined tequila that exemplifies the traditional reposado style.

Its smooth and balanced profile makes it a top choice for discerning margarita enthusiasts.

This tequila is perfect for crafting Cadillac margaritas, a luxurious variation with premium ingredients like Grand Marnier.

La Gran Señora Reposado offers a harmonious blend of agave sweetness and subtle vanilla notes imparted by the aging process.

The vanilla adds a delicate creaminess to the margarita, while the agave provides a foundation of authentic flavor.

Pairing Suggestions: In addition to margaritas, La Gran Señora Reposado pairs beautifully with rich, savory dishes like grilled meats or mole sauces.

6. ElVelo Blanco

ElVelo Blanco

ElVelo Blanco boasts a higher-than-average proof at 44.5% ABV, giving it an extra presence in cocktails.

This tequila is custom-designed with bartenders and mixology in mind, ensuring a standout margarita experience.

On the palate, ElVelo Blanco offers notes of fresh-cut grass, ripe stone fruit, and a hint of mint.

These flavors provide a vibrant and refreshing foundation for a margarita.

This tequila shines in classic tequila preparations, including margaritas.

Its higher proof and distinct flavor profile make it a top choice for crafting incredible margaritas that leave a lasting impression.

7. Siembra Valles High-Proof Blanco

Siembra Valles High-Proof Blanco

Siembra Valles High-Proof Blanco showcases a bright, bold agave character achieved through traditional production methods.

Slow-cooked agave, tahona crushing, and copper pot distillation produce a flavorful and robust tequila.

This high-proof blanco features intense notes of licorice, black pepper, and freshly cut grass.

These flavors create a complex, assertive profile that stands out in a margarita.

Siembra Valles High-Proof Blanco is perfect for crafting bold, full-flavored margaritas.

Its pronounced agave character and spicy notes can handle adding other ingredients without getting lost in the mix.

8. Maestro Dobel Diamante


Maestro Dobel Diamante is a unique cristalino tequila that combines the complexity of aged tequilas with the clarity of a blanco.

Aged in oak barrels and filtered to remove color, this tequila offers a luxurious and smooth profile.

On the palate, Maestro Dobel Diamante reveals notes of vanilla, prickly pear, and subtle oak.

These flavors create a rich and sophisticated backdrop for a margarita.

This Cristalino tequila is ideal for crafting decadent, high-end margaritas.

Its smooth, refined character adds a touch of elegance to the classic cocktail, making it perfect for special occasions or impressing guests.

9. Santo Puro Mezquila

Santo Puro Mezquila

Santo Puro Mezquila is an innovative blend of tequila and mezcal, combining the best spirits.

This unique fusion combines the smooth, agave-forward notes of tequila with the smoky, earthy character of mezcal.

Santo Puro Mezquila offers a harmonious balance of tequila’s fruity notes and mezcal’s smoky, earthy tones.

The result is a complex and intriguing flavor profile that adds depth to a margarita.

This tequila is perfect for crafting unique, smoky margaritas with a twist.

Adding mezcal’s smoky notes brings a new dimension to the classic cocktail, appealing to those who enjoy a hint of smoke in their drinks.

10. Ghost Blanco

Ghost Blanco

Ghost Blanco is a unique tequila infused with natural flavors, including a noticeable peppery heat. While the aroma is deceptively sweet and vegetal, the palate reveals a lively, spicy kick.

This Blanco tequila offers vegetal, green notes on the nose, with just a hint of the heat to come.

The peppery spice takes center stage on the palate, providing a stimulating and fiery experience.

Ghost Blanco is perfect for crafting spicy margaritas with an extra kick.

The tequila’s inherent heat pairs beautifully with a Tajin-salted rim, creating a dynamic and exciting cocktail experience.

11. Volans Tequila Blanco

Volans Tequila Blanco

Volans Tequila Blanco is a vibrant and expressive tequila with bright, fruity, and floral notes.

Crafted using traditional methods, it captures the essence of the blue Weber agave in its purest form.

On the palate, Volans Tequila Blanco offers a delightful interplay of citrus, tropical fruit, and floral notes.

A subtle savory undertone adds complexity and depth to the overall flavor profile.

This Blanco tequila is ideal for creating fall margaritas incorporating seasonal ingredients like blood orange or pomegranate.

Its bright, lively character complements the rich, autumnal flavors, resulting in a festive and delicious cocktail.


Exploring the world of tequila and its role in crafting the perfect margarita is an exciting journey for any cocktail enthusiast.

Each tequila, from the vibrant Blancos to the rich reposados and the intriguing, high-proof, smoky variants, brings a unique character to the beloved margarita.

By selecting the right tequila for your taste preferences and the occasion, you can elevate your margarita game and impress your guests with a truly exceptional cocktail experience.

So, whether you prefer classic lime-forward flavors or crave a spicy kick, this guide has provided you with the knowledge and recommendations to create extraordinary margaritas.

Grab your shaker, gather your ingredients, and mix up some margarita magic. Salud!

Viktor Edwards
Viktor Edwards

Viktor Edwards brings over a decade of experience to his craft, having honed his skills in some of the most renowned establishments. A graduate with a degree in Culinary Arts from the prestigious Culinary Institute of America, Viktor's journey into the world of fine drinks began shortly after completing his education. His career took off when he joined our website's team in 2021, bringing with him a passion for creating innovative beverages that tantalize the palate while offering a nod to classic flavors. Beyond his professional pursuits, Viktor is an avid cyclist and enjoys exploring the great outdoors, believing that inspiration can be found in the natural world around us.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *