How to Make Air Fryer Mahi Mahi in a Few Simple Steps


It’s a super lazy day; imagine wanting to eat Mahi Mahi fish and get it in minutes! Yes, that’s possible now because we’ve brought you the Air Fryer Mahi Mahi recipe. Picture this: succulent Mahi Mahi fillets, delicately seasoned with a symphony of herbs and spices, all cradled in the tender embrace of the air fryer.

In just a few minutes, you’ll witness a symphony of sizzling aromas that will fill your kitchen with an irresistible anticipation of what’s to come. With this Mahi Mahi recipe, preparing fish will become your favorite “go-to food,” it cooks perfectly in an air fryer and will win you over.

So get ready to enjoy the delicious culinary trip of this Mahi Mahi fish, which is exceedingly simple to prepare and rewards your tongue with its incredibly distinctive flavor.

Take the supplies and your time, and let’s try it!

What is Mahi Mahi?

What is Mahi Mahi?

Mahi Mahi, also known as Dolphin fish, is most frequently discovered in the Indian Ocean, Costa Rica, Hawaii, and the Gulf of Mexico. This fish has a flat surface and no fish-like smell, which is why many people prefer it.

Since the fish meat has a fairly neutral flavor, it is simple to season and a great option for a fish meal as it gets cooked comparatively well and equally to other fishes. Let’s get started with the recipe now!

Prep Time Along with Other Essentials with The Mahi Mahi Recipe

The Mahi Mahi recipe is a super delight without much effort and time!

Preparation time

5 Minutes

Cooking time

15 Minutes


4 Servings

The cooking time also depends on the model number of the Airy fryer we’re using. Some air fryers take less time and have temperature controls than others. So, its always better to know the Air fryer’s temperature controls before using it.

The above timings and the servings are given as per the ingredients of the Mahi Mahi recipe. Now that the timings and portions are put forward let’s move on to the ingredients needed for this dish.



Use the ingredients below to start a flavorful journey and create a mouthwatering fish with this Mahi Mahi recipe.

Mahi Mahi FishTake one pound of Mahi Mahi (3-4 fish fillets) of similar size so that all cooking time is needed.
OilAvocado oil or olive oil can be used. If both aren’t available, regular oil can be used.
PaprikaGives a sweet chili flavor.
Salt and PepperThe finest flavor comes from freshly ground black pepper.
GarlicEither granulated garlic or garlic powder can be used.
Herb Garlic ButterThis butter can also be made at home using garlic, butter, and seasonings. An alternative to garlic butter is normal butter, which can also be used.
Lemon JuiceSqueeze lemons to have fresh lemon juice to give your mahi mahi recipe a tangy flavor.
HerbsFreshly chopped herbs like parsley or chives to garnish the dish.

These ingredients can help you cook the Mahi Mahi recipe in a super authentic and flavorful way. After these ingredients, knowing the proper kitchen tools is a must!

Kitchen Tools and Essentials

To make any filling food, a set of kitchen tools is essentially needed. For the mahi mahi recipe, below are the tools needed:

1. Air Fryer

Air Fryer

The air fryer is one must-have kitchen tool for this Air fryer mahi mahi recipe, which is super easy to cook. The air fryer is a modern kitchen essential that eliminates the traditional methods of cooking fish and using so much oil.

Just coat the fish, brush up some oil on it, and keep it in the Air fryer tray for 10-15 mins. Voila! Your fish is ready to eat!

2. Oil Brush or Spray

Oil Brush or Spray

Oil brush or spay, any one of them, is necessary for applying oil on mahi mahi after keeping it in the Air fryer for cooking. The mahi mahi recipe is easy and breezy, but with this oil brush or spray, it can also be less clumsy.

3. Parchment Paper or Aluminium Foil

Parchment Paper or Aluminium Foil

A kitchen necessity that is always required for dishes cooked in an air fryer is parchment paper or aluminum foil. Mahi Mahi is less likely to stick to the basket when shielded with parchment paper or aluminum foil. This is because meat, if kept directly without the paper or the foil, can sometimes get stuck to the basket due to temperature changes.

4. Wide Bowl or Plate

Wide Bowl or Plate

To season the Mahi Mahi properly, it is recommended to use plates or bowls that are wide so that the fish fillets can be coated and seasoned equally and nicely. Wider the bowl, super nice the coating of seasonings. Also, wider bowls or plates can avoid clumsiness while seasoning.

5. Fork


Fork is a readily available kitchen tool, and for this Mahi Mahi recipe, it can play a big role. A fork is needed to check the internal cooking of the fish fillet after taking it out of the Air fryer. The Mahi Mahi is perfectly cooked and ready to eat if the fork gets through the fish meat smoothly. If the fork doesn’t pass through the fish fillet, then the meat needs more cooking to be perfect for eating.

These are the five basic kitchen tools needed for the Mahi Mahi recipe. Using these tools ensures you eat a delicious and perfectly cooked Mahi Mahi! We now have the ingredients and kitchen tools needed for this food delight, so it’s time to get on with the main plot- The recipe!

Step-By-Step Guide for the Mahi Mahi Recipe

This fish treat is simplest to make, and with the Airy fryer, it gets even much easier. Here are some directions to follow for cooking this flaky Mahi Mahi.

Step 1: Preheat the Air Fryer

Preheat the Air Fryer

Preheating the air fryer is the first step. This ensures that the mahi mahi is cooked properly and equally and doesn’t dry out in the air fryer. Preheating the air fryer also depends on the model as well. Some models do not require as much preheating and can give the instant heat required by the dish. So, its always better to check the air fryer model you will use for preparing this dish.

Step 2: Clean the Fish

Clean the Fish

After preheating the air fryer and before starting the mahi mahi recipe, it’s very important to clean the fish with water and ensure it is rubbed well so all the dirt is removed. Once this is done, using a fresh piece of paper towel, dry the Mahi Mahi fillets properly and keep them in a bowl where they can be seasoned completely.

Step 3: Prepare the Seasoning

Prepare the Seasoning

Take a bowl or a plate and add all the ingredients and spices like ground black pepper, salt, paprika, garlic (powder or granulated), parsley, or chives. Mix them all well and keep them aside.

The seasoning mix can be altered per individual preferences, like adding oregano, chili flakes, garlic powder, basils, onion powder, thyme, etc. These ingredients can be mixed with an appropriate quantity for an extra punch of flavor to this mahi mahi recipe.

Step 4: Brush the Fish with Oil and Season it

Brush the Fish with Oil and Season it

Take the Mahi Mahi and brush it with oil. After doing so, start seasoning the fish with the seasoning prepared in Step 3. Make sure that the seasoning is applied well to both sides of Mahi Mahi because applying seasoning properly ensures that the flavors are spread equally. With each bite, flavors can be felt across the tasting buds. Let the mahi mahi be kept for 10-12 mins in the air fryer so that it cooks properly.

Step 5: Garnishing Your Mahi Mahi Recipe

Garnishing Your Mahi Mahi Recipe

Once the Mahi Mahi is cooked, remove it from the air fryer and keep it on the serving plate. Try gently inserting a fork to check if the fish is cooked completely. Once the fish is cooked properly, apply some herb garlic butter and squeeze some lemon juice onto it for a fresh taste.

The butter and the lemon enhance the taste of this mahi mahi recipe in a very tangy way and make sure that the flavor of this fish tantalizes your taste buds. This Mahi Mahi recipe can be plated with rice, noodles, or any simple vegetable.

This easy-to-make Mahi Mahi recipe is a treat for yourself on busy and boring days. With the sweet, tangy, and spicy flavor, you will turn this filling food into your favorite comfort meal. This recipe is super easy to cook, but there are a few things to be careful about when going for this Mahi Mahi recipe.

Things to Adhere while Preparing the Mahi Mahi Recipe

Things to Adhere while Preparing the Mahi Mahi Recipe

While cooking this mahi mahi recipe, every step of the recipe above has to be followed carefully so that you don’t miss out on the flavorful taste of the dish. Let’s look at some things to be very careful about:

  • Cooking Time and Temperature: It’s crucial to adhere to the particular directions for your type of air fryer because temperature and cooking times differ. Generally, mahi mahi cooks best around 375°F (190°C) for 10 to 12 minutes; however, you should vary this time depending on the size and thickness of your fillets.
  • Preheating the Air Fryer: Before preparing any food, including Mahi Mahi, always preheat your air fryer—preheating guarantees consistent cooking and aids in getting that crunchy surface.
  • The thickness of Mahi Mahi: To achieve consistent cooking, ensure the Airy fryer is filled with equal thickness for each fish fillet. If there’s any fish fillet that is different in thickness, group it with similar ones or try cooking it separately to get the required cooking time. It needs to be tender enough.
  • Avoid Overcooking: Mahi Mahi is a delicate fish that can turn fry if it’s overcooked. Ensure that the temperature of the air fryer is perfect and is cooked at an appropriate time. To check the internal cooking of the mahi mahi, gently insert the fork in the center and check if it smoothly comes out to the other side. If it is still uncooked, cook it with your estimation of the temperature and time.
  • Use Parchment Paper or Aluminium Foil: Place a piece of parchment paper or aluminum foil in the air fryer basket before adding the fish fillets to reduce the risk that the fish will stick to the basket.
  • Capacity of Air Fryer: Ensure the fish does not overcrowd the air fryer basket because it can lead to undercooking fish fillets. Check the basket size and adjust the fish fillets accordingly, ensuring that the pieces keep getting enough space to cook completely and properly.
  • Seasoning Quantity: Using the appropriate quantity of each spice to make the seasoning can ensure that every flavor revolves around your taste buds when taking the first bite. Adding any spice, more or less, will break the taste of this mahi mahi recipe.
  • Seasoning Alteration: The amount and taste of the seasoning mix can be changed to suit personal preferences. A tasty mahi mahi recipe must include components that can improve the taste of the mahi mahi. Still, the taste and quantity of the ingredients must be carefully considered.

These are a few important things to remember while opting for this Mahi Mahi recipe. Ensuring that everything is in place, this Mahi Mahi recipe can surely be a winning dish for you all the time, be it lazy or happy, because of its delightful taste and nutritional facts!

Nutritional Content

Due to its low-fat cooking process, the Airfryer mahi mahi recipe is a nutritional and healthy choice, which retails its natural vitamins and mineral for even food lovers and the health-conscious ones as well.

The cooking process keeps the fish’s protein intact while reducing unhealthy saturated fats, making it super delicious and wholesome for a balanced diet. The nutritional facts for this mahi mahi recipe per serving are:

Total Calories






Considering this healthy mahi mahi recipe, you can treat your taste buds guilt-free!

To Summarize

The Air Fryer Mahi Mahi recipe is a culinary gem, having delightful flavors without compromising your health. Its easy preparation, convenience, and efficient cooking make this a perfect choice of easy-to-cook filling food for everyone anytime.

This cooking process with an air fryer ensures that fish retains its original flavor with crispy outer, tender meat, and a flavorful dining experience without using much oil, like in traditional methods of preparing this Mahi recipe.

This recipe almost draws everybody because of its healthy benefits and nutritional facts. With this dish, you can impress your family or friends with minimal time in the kitchen and maximum time with them. So, take your air fryer and spices and get on with this Mahi Mahi recipe.

Let us know what you think about this self-treat in the comments below!

Jamie Oliver
Jamie Oliver

Jamie Oliver is a culinary maestro with over 25 years of experience who brings a wealth of knowledge to our culinary section. He graduated with honors in Culinary Arts and Food Service Management, which laid the groundwork for his illustrious career. He holds a Master’s in Gastronomy and has enriched our culinary content since 2017. His prior experience includes executive chef positions at high-end eateries and authoring several cookbooks. And his approach to cooking emphasizes sustainability and locally sourced ingredients. He is a great gardener as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *